Flatlay of whole Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo) open face with stars cut from crust on top

Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo)

This Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo) brings fun back to summer food for those of us avoiding gluten, processed sugar, etc. Use your favorite crust, or borrow mine!

Flatlay of whole Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo) open face with stars cut from crust on top
Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo)
Jump to Recipe

I’ve been wanting to make a blueberry pie for some time now. Every summer, when plump, ripe berries are plentiful, I want to add those beauties to everything! (See Blueberry BBQ Sauce, and Banana Blueberry Muffins, etc.)

Closeup of one blueberry-smeared star made of crust atop the Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo)
Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo)

You won’t need any special equipment to make the filling. I decided to make this one on the stove because I wanted more control over the texture. I first tried an uncooked blueberry filling in my crust. The result was… ahem… sub-optimal. ๐Ÿ˜†

Undeterred, I attempted making the filling on the stove. Now the magic began! Speaking of magic, the magic ingredient in this filling is arrowroot starch/flour. This is the stuff that holds it all together. It has the consistency of corn starch, but works way better as a thickener, IMO. Don’t be afraid of unfamiliar ingredients! Try ’em!

One piece of Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo) garnished with lemon zest and pansies
Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo)

You should know…

Every time I post a baking recipe, I feel a responsibility to manage expectations. If you’re new to this way of eating, you may be expecting that baking will work just like you’re used to, for things to taste exactly the same, to have the same mouth feel, etc. AIP baking is tricky. I’m not gonna lie. If you are having a challenging time, reach out, and I’ll do my best to help you troubleshoot.

Closeup of half-eaten piece of Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo) on a blueberry-smeared plate with a fork
Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo)

But take heart!

You CAN actually bake on the AIP/Paleo diet! Once you shift your mindset, you can enjoy baking again. Just remember – everything in moderation. You can quickly de-rail your healing by indulging in a few too many treats!

OK, we good? Right. Let’s get us some PIE!

As always, I’m wishing you great love and deep healing.



Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo)

Recipe by Wendi’s AIP Kitchen – http://www.wendisaipkitchen.com Course: Treats and SnacksCuisine: AIP, PaleoDifficulty: Medium


9-inch pie
Prep time


Cooking time



This Blueberry Pie (AIP/Paleo) brings fun back to summer food for those of us avoiding gluten, processed sugar, etc. Use your favorite crust, or borrow mine!


  • 1 1 pie crust, 9″ (Use your favorite, or borrow mine!)

  • 6 cups 6 fresh blueberries

  • 1/4 cup 1/4 honey

  • Zest of one lemon

  • 1/2 tsp 1/2 alcohol-free vanilla

  • 1/4 tsp 1/4 salt

  • 1/4 tsp 1/4 cinnamon

  • 1/4 cup 1/4 arrowroot starch/flour

  • Juice of one lemon

  • 2 TBSP 2 water

  • Coconut milk for brushing (optional)


  • Roll out one pie crust, and lay it in a 9″ pie plate. Gently press the crust into place. If making a 1-crust pie, crimp the edges, then prick the bottom and sides with a fork. If making a 2-crust pie, wait to crimp the edges until the pie is filled and topped. (Note: if using my crust recipe, note that the recipe makes ONE crust.) Set aside. Pre-heat oven to 350 degrees F.
  • Place blueberries, honey, lemon zest, vanilla, salt, and cinnamon in a large saucepan. Place arrowroot starch, lemon juice, and water in a container with a tight-fitting lid. Shake it vigorously to combine. Add to the saucepan.
  • Turn heat under the saucepan to medium. As it cooks, mash the berries gently. (Leave some berries intact.) Mash and cook for 5 minutes. The liquid will go from pink to lavender, to finally a rich blueberry color. Cook for a few more minutes until it thickens.
  • Fill the crust with blueberry filling. If desired (for browning), brush crust with coconut milk. Bake for 30 minutes. If you are making a 2-crust pie, be sure to cut vents into the top crust before baking. See further notes below.
  • Let the pie cool completely before serving. Refrigerating the pie will further hold it together, if desired. Enjoy your pie! ๐Ÿ˜‹


  • This recipe is for an open-face pie. To get the look I created here, make extra pie crust, cut out shapes, place on a cookie sheet, and cook them separately for 10 minutes. Place them on the pie when it has cooked and set.
  • If you make a 2-crust pie using my crust recipe, bake for 40 minutes.
  • Prep times do not include time to make the crust. If you are using my crust, count on about 30 minutes for making and forming the crust.
  • The filling can be made the day before and refrigerated.

We are a participant in the Amazon.com Services LLC Associates program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.


  1. Just noticed this recipe didn’t have any reviews and that is a shame! I made this probably 5 times last summer when blueberries were in season. It was delicious and easy to make. Shared it with several people who were not AIP or Paleo and everyone loved it. So good!

  2. Can you replace blueberries with apples?

  3. I have looked at the enchiladas. They look amazing! Thank you

  4. Pingback: Frozen Monkey Bars (AIP/Paleo) - Wendi's AIP Kitchen

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.